Opinion Editorial to Board of Ed: "Recognize Our Dismal Rankings"

The following letter was written to the Board of Education by Bloomfield parent, Bea Binkowska and presented during the public portion of Tuesday night's meeting.

Dear Members of the Board,

It has recently come to my attention that Franklin School's rating on the GreatSchools.org website has fallen from an already low rating of ‘six’ to ‘four’ and that is on a scale of ten. What is more, in a recent ranking of high schools by NJ Monthly magazine, Bloomfield ranked 221 on a list of about 315 schools. This is 61 spots below Belleville and 81 spots lower than Nutley, which I personally find inexplicable, as it is my understanding that Bloomfield population does not vary from general population of NJ by any measure – therefore, at a minimum, I would expect at least average performance, and personally, I would hope that we can strive to do better than that.

As a parent of a 4th grade student, and a tax payer who is burdened with a property tax bill in excess of $10,000 per year, I am at a loss as to why there are no more radical changes made to remedy this situation. In my view, our schools are systematically failing the population of this town, and when I am talking about the town, I am not merely referring to students and their parents, such as myself, but all the property owners, because we all well know that the quality of the school system plays a large role in determining property values. Why else would a house on a Glen Ridge side of Essex Avenue be 50%-80% more expensive than a comparable house on a Bloomfield side?

Therefore, I hope that this board and the superintendent are as aware and concerned about those developments, as I am and are taking aggressive steps to remedy this situation with a sense of urgency this warrants.

Between my two kids, we have been at Franklin continuously for the last eight years, and we have seen no such substantive changes in that period. The current rankings suggest we are not addressing this problem. I offer a list of improvements that I would hope to see as a parent:

- It seems to me that different kids have different needs and they learn in different ways, so why not create a magnet system (within the under-performing schools, obviously there are 2-3 schools in town that perform well and we should let them be). The schools I envision would have specializations that align with interests and needs of the student body they serve. So perhaps, we could have a school with bilingual teachers, who could assist children with limited proficiency in English in making a transition; have a separate school for kids who are interested in science and a school with emphasis on art. What all those schools would have in common would be strict, challenging curriculum and teachers who love to teach it. And yes, I would love to see after-school clubs that are not athletic.

- Introduce a real gifted program, surely we can round up 20-40 gifted children at each grade level in a town of 48,000 people.

- Some of the teachers, my children were lucky to have, were easily worth their weight in gold - they loved teaching, they loved working with children, and they instilled a love of learning in their students. Funny thing is that everybody knows who those teachers are and everybody knows, which of the teachers do not fall into that category, but for some reason it seems to be a taboo subject - here is why it should not be: according to Malcolm Gladwell, who attributes this research to Eric Hanushek, an economist at Stanford, "students of a very bad teacher will learn, on average, half a year’s worth of material in one school year. The students in the class of a very good teacher will learn a year and a half’s worth of material. That difference amounts to a year’s worth of learning in a single year." This is the very reason why we should not hesitate to broach the subject and insist that we modify our current performance evaluation system for the benefit of the students who attend our schools.

- Establish and enforce strict residency criteria, so we can be sure that our property taxes benefit our residents and only our residents.

- Improve school schedule – we have a high number of half-days and seemingly random days off. Certainly, test scores point to our students needing more rather than less classroom instruction and this schedule makes it very difficult for the working parents. I have previously written to the board regarding what I consider a frivolous number of November school closures, I believe when I added up all the full-days and the hours of all the half-days due to parent-teacher conferences, and subtracted all the days off due to a teacher's convention a Thanksgiving holiday - I got an equivalent of 13 full days of instruction during the entire month of November.


I call upon our Board of Education and the school leadership to take the first step today - recognize our dismal rankings for what they are - a failure. And then take the second step - seize upon this failure by not being satisfied with incremental improvements here or there, but as a call to action to take substantive steps to elevate the performance of the school system. 

Peter L September 14, 2012 at 01:42 AM
It is all about the public trust or in reality the lack of it....the aforementioned comments are on target and for this to occur (terrible scores and placement)someone using our public trust failed.....its quite simple "just do the right thing" Money is not the answer 20K spent on inner city kids not much for that. God help us
Name Not Provided September 14, 2012 at 06:23 PM
This letter is beautifully written--well spoken and throughtfully addressed the EAXACT issues and frustrations that I have articulated for several years. These are also the reasons that I will not send my child to the Bloomfield schools. Which is a shame--because I love the area and our home-- but realize that it makes more sense to move to the othere side of "Essex St." than to wait for the school board to wake up!
Karen Banda September 15, 2012 at 05:25 AM
Many decades ago, I thought I was an idiot when it came to math. It just didn't compute. My teacher could just as well have been speaking in Greek for all the sense it made to me. I constantly pulled D with a red underline. Borderline failure. Then we had a practice teacher for one semester. Wow! It all made sense! I wasn't stupid! Sadly, the PT left and the regular teacher returned. D with a red underline. Again. In Bloomfield HS I was blessed to have to wonderful math teachers in Gabe Mosso and Ms. Carter (Geometry). I wasn't great, but I didn't fail. I had hope. When I went to college I had to take remedial algebra as I totally tanked that part of the SATs while achieving a perfect score in English. Again, I had someone who was able to teach and did extremely well in a comprehensive summer semester. It took until my late 20's to realize the problem wasn't me. It was the people teaching me. I actually did extremely well in accounting and statistics in college. Go figure. It IS about the teachers. Just saying.
sheltershowcase September 16, 2012 at 07:45 PM
I would love to learn more and work towards improving our school system. It is very true that this is important for our children, and property values as well. Bea, I would love to connect with you and others interested in this cause. I created a Facebook group, as a starting place. Please join if you want to connect: http://www.facebook.com/groups/365589853515394/
patricia marinaro September 16, 2012 at 10:48 PM
yep. hang in there.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »